So on Monday (9th November) I received a text message from our Yoga teacher that the lesson on Monday night would be her last class, as I turned up for the lesson, she told me that she wasn’t getting the numbers she needed to continue the lessons, and she may look into something after the New Year, but she wasn’t sure what time or day that would be, only that it wouldn’t be the same time slot (Monday night).
Karen, my wife has several underlying health issues, so her weekly Yoga class was doing her a lot of good, it also gave her a mood bust, which in turn encouraged her to exercise (even if just chair based) during the week.
I was also feeling the benefit of the deep stretching of Yoga and was beginning to enjoy the practice.
So what is the tough choice?
Well the other class in our local area (the class my wife and I actually begun with, almost two years ago) is on a Tuesday, the same night as my Tai Chi class.
That is the choice I was forced to make, to continue my Tai Chi or continue our Yoga.
I found that I couldn’t turn my back on the health benefits we were both getting from Yoga, so taking a long term health centred view of the situation, I’ve chosen to continue with our Yoga practice.
Initially it seemed a fairly easy choice, I’m was definitely getting more direct physical health benefits from Yoga, and as I explained in last months post, I was beginning to have some mixed feeling about my Tai Chi practice.
However as class drew to a close last night, I felt really sad, not because of any deep love of Tai Chi, but because I was walking away from a great bunch of people, and from one of those rare things you sometimes find in life…a great teacher,
Maybe things will change, perhaps the ‘Monday’ class will re-open again, and I will be able to go back to the Tai Chi class, and maybe not.
Is this the end of my Tai Chi journey, to be honest, I don’t think so, I do think that I will take up the practice again, maybe not that class, teacher or even style, but I do think at some point in the future I will take up the practice again.
So that’s, that, sometimes when you think you have life figured out, it kicks you in the balls, but as the world turns and another day begins, all we can do is keep putting one foot in front of the other and hope the choices we make are the right ones.
(Next months blog for December, I will close out the year, with some ‘words of wisdom’ from my teachers)
Train true , train hard, train often.
So in October i’ll celebrate my first year in Wu style Taiji quan (Tai Chi Chaun).
Although I started Tai Chi in the larger sense in August 2025, however this style wasn’t a recognised or authentic system, more of a modern hybrid, (with a dubious origin).
I may write about this next year.
So why Tai Chi?
I was trying to take a long term view, after four decades of training, my body carries several injuries and as I age, these won’t be getting any better.
So I was looking for a martial arts based system that I could practice fully into my later years.
I’ve always been intrigued when watching people practice Tai Chi, the very relaxed flowing movements.
However if you’re expecting to just stand around and waft your arms (or undertake one of those new internet based Tai Chi walking fitness regimes) then you’ll be quite surprised on how intricate and technical it is.
In fact it is one of the most, if not the most technical system I have taken part in, its is at once intriguing and infuriating – like a perfectly ripe piece of fruit, just slightly out of grasp.
It is certainly not what I thought it would be.
With the length of the form, I’m finding it hard to remember just less than about a third, at the moment, in fact, I’m finding it more of a memory test, than anything else.
One of the issues I’m experiencing when trying to practice at home, is the lack of space to do the form (as I live in an apartment, and don’t have a garden) having to shuffle about, as the form isn’t symmetrical, unlike like many forms and kata.
Do I feel that I’m gaining any particular benefits from my Tai Chi practice?
Well to be perfectly honest, no not really. But then again, I’m also practising Wing Chun and Yoga, so maybe If I wasn’t doing these, then I may have a different opinion, with some gentle physical exercise and body movement.
So will I be celebrating my tenth anniversary in 2035?
To be honest I don’t know, I can see me continuing my practice for the next couple of years, trying to learn to long form, although maybe if I find some inspiring text or some mental breakthrough, or perhaps if my Wing Chun practice comes to an unexpected end, hen who knows.
So that’s my first year of Tai Chi practice, with hopefully many more to come.
Train true, train hard, train often.
So September 2026 I can celebrate ten years in Wing Chun (actually this is my eleventh year) but this is my tenth continuous year.
So although this may seem something to celebrate, it also means that it is ten years since I last practised Aikido.
It was a warm June night, when we finally bowed out of the small rural church hall, this night however instead of moving all the mats into the small shed, we loaded some into a van, some had already been sold.
Sensei had given us a months notice, that he was closing the dojo, enough time to get Ian and myself through our 3rd Kyu grades and time for us to make other plans.
Sensei had asked me what I was going to do next, as he knew I had transferred from traditional Aikido (as a 2nd Dan) to once again wear a white belt in the Ki Aikido system he taught.
This was a good question, what was I going to do?
I could go back to traditional Aikido, although I felt that I had burnt too many bridges, it meant a lot of travelling (and we were planning on selling our car) and I had started to have pain in my lower back when doing breakfalls.
I mentioned to Sensei that I had previously done a year of Wing Chun, and I would like to explore the possibility of returning to that system.
After deciding to take a few weeks to consider my options, at this time I was going to a gym, to improve my cardio and functional strength training, they had an upstairs fitness studio, and one night they had flyers for new classes, one was a Wing Chun class.
The Sifu there was Carlos Lewis, chief instructor of Direct Martial Arts, who had trained originally under Sifu William Lai (Chu Shong Tin lineage) and was now studying under Grand Master Samuel Kwok, (and is one of the few professional instructors, I’ve trained under).
A week later, I returned to my Wing Chun training, the classes were much more energetic than my previous training, with stamina and cardio being included in the lessons.
I continued my training over the next few years, even when the class moved location a couple of times.
Training was going well, until March 2020, when the global covid pandemic hit, and Sifu initially moved the classes on-line, however these became fairly sporadic and poorly attended (usually only two of us).
Also as you can imagine, with a ‘hands-on’ system like Wing Chun, we were fairly limited in what we could cover on-line, this did however mean I was able to move onto some senior forms including the wooden dummy form.
In August 2021, the association sent out an email, letting us know that there would be no more classes until further notice.
Was this to mirror my experience in Aikido, and put an end to my training?
Well I had somewhat of a backup plan, I had been communicating with Sifu Dave Lovegrove, over the last couple of years, a highly respected Wing Chun instructor in Australia.
So from August 2021 to the spring of 2022 I became an online student of Sifu Lovegrove, I will never forget the kindness of this highly regarded teacher taking me under his wing as the world was struggling to recover from the effects of the pandemic.
The spring of 2022, saw the easing of many of the restrictions and sports groups could start to train again, at this time, Sifu Lovegrove returned to work and our lessons together sadly came to an end.
Although the good news was that our association, was planning on reopening, a full two years since the end of our last physical class, with another change of venue.
However there seemed to be a change in Sifu and his attitude towards the class, with very little lesson structure or planning, and him being absent from many classes.
So I made the decision to change clubs, (in hindsight was this the right decision? I’m fairly certain at the time it was).
In April 2022, I returned to my very first Wing Chun Sifu (Sifu Nigel Rees) whom I had trained with eight years previously, he had now broken away from the academy and was running classes as an independent instructor.
Sifu teaches in a very traditional way, without student grades or certified assessments, and although classes are only small, progress is very slow, as we follow a training syllabus based upon previous academy grade syllabus (but without the actual grade promotions).
So although was enjoying my training (and still am) , I realised I wouldn’t be able to continue my grade progress that I had taken with the previous association.
To this end, beginning in November 2023 I began an online Wing Chun course (along side my physical lessons) with Sifu Mark Beardsell (Student of Grand Master Sam Kwok).
So that’s where I am ten years later, having physical weekly lessons with my Sifu in the Ip Chun lineage, along side my online course working through the system (and gaining certification for each level passed, in the Sam Kwok lineage). It hasn’t been easy, having in effect to learn the forms twice, and as I mentioned early about the hindsight, being right at that moment in time, should I have stayed with my previous association?
To be honest I’m not sure, But this is my martial arts journey, and no one said it should be easy.
That’s it for this month.
Train true, train hard, train often.
So this is the second part to this article ‘It could be better’ which I originally intended to be a single piece, and it grew into a two parter.
Last month we looked at giving feedback (as an instructor correcting students) and what makes good feedback, we looked at 4 different ‘Instructor examples’ or teaching styles.
So I would recommend reading that post first.
This month we will be looking at the same situation from the students point of view.
So for the majority of this article we will work under the assumption that you are being taught by a suitably qualified and experienced instructor, with a good attitude with their students and generally all round a ‘good egg’ as they say in old blighty.
This would be the 3rd model from last month i.e. spotting the issue, giving supportive feedback, and finding a solution to the problem, with the bonus of giving the student goals they can work to correct their technique.
So why can feedback be difficult to accept, I guess we can expand this to include general barriers to learning.
As we discussed in last month, teaching isn’t a one size fits all, people (and therefore students) learn differently.
So I will outline some reasons (or causes) as to why students sometimes struggle to receive the feedback or correction, with some solutions and pepper in a few personal examples.
A clash of personalities – Traditional martial arts should begin and end with humility (a bow) so we need to be in the right frame of mind to receive that teaching, we are seeking tuition from someone more qualified and experienced than ourselves, so by being humble we are breaking down our own ego (which can be a big obstacle), now call me old fashioned and maybe I am, but in society today, there seems to be a general lack of respect given to seniors and people in authority these days, so when young people first experience this shift in attitudes in the dojo, it may be off putting.
So the experienced Instructor will be able to explain all this and break it down, for the beginner, and as everyone else in class are following the same etiquette guidelines, the student should start to feel more comfortable with them.
A small note of caution here, being humble doesn’t mean being a doormat, and sometimes it is the attitude of the instructor, which is the issue, but that recognition usually comes through experience, so just bare that in mind.
Language barriers, so this is another very common barrier to learning, especially in the traditional Asian martial arts, as there is a new language to learn, which for senior students or Instructors they may be like second nature, but to the new student it may be very confusing.
This can be an issue, when attending seminars with invited guests from abroad, who do not speak your language,and work through interpreters.
So introduce, terminology slowly, perhaps the age of the A4 hand outs is a bit old, so look at new ways to reach students using social media or other modern technologies.
Inconsistent tuition, this can be when you are in a large school, and the senior instructor, breaks the class into smaller groups led by one of their senior grades, adding their own emphasis to the teaching, which may not be what the instructor wants for that group, at that level.
So I experienced this many years ago learning a form, the instructor had given us a certain sequence to practice, then sent a class senior over to our group, who began to spend most of the leeson on something else.
Another example was when an Aikido club I trained at, had a syllabus update, and this caused confusion sometimes being taught the ‘old’ way to do the technique, and sometimes the ‘new’ way the association wanted it done.
On a similar note, if your training at home (and of course you should) make sure you are practising what you have been taught, if you are going to use social media and ‘Sensei youtube’ to support your learning make sure its a source recommended by your instructor (or better yet, your Instructors own videos online) otherwise you may go down a rabbit hole of different schools and styles which can cause a great deal frustration and confusion.
My advise to support your home learning is to keep a training journal, this can be a written note book, a sketch pad, an online graphics package or video notes – whatever works best for you, and make a note of the feedback and corrections you received in class, and use this as your ‘homework’.
I’m also a big believer that learning martial arts should go beyond the physical, and your home practice should include reading books, magazines, online articles and even blogs (like this one) to support your learning and development.
A sure sign of a good teacher is one that encourages their students to ask questions, however you need to ask the questions respectfully and of course ask the right questions.
Although as a bit of a ‘tradional-ist’ I like the sense of etiquette and discipline in class, I don’t think the atmosphere should be too austere in the training hall, we as students are choosing to spend our (precious) time there, and so if the instructors create an oppressive environment, students will vote with their feet and go elsewhere – this can definitely put people off learning.
On the other hand however if the teacher uses too much humour and there are no (or very loosely) rules of behaviour this can lead to very unruly lessons and make it very difficult to learn he finer points of the martial arts.
At the end of the day your instructor is making you a better person through your training, if you receive critical feedback don’t take it personally, take your ego out of the equation. Your teacher may see some great potentiation in you, and are are trying to improve your skill set so you can carry on their art, to the next generation.
I’ll finish this 2 part article, with a story told to me by one of my Aikido Sensei (the late Billy McCauley)
So Billy spent ten years in Japan studying Aikido under Kinjo Asoh Sensei (A student of O’Sensei)
On one occasion, after class, Billy was walking down the stairs, he met a fellow western student and Billy’s sempai, Niall going upstairs, Billy must have looked crestfallen, as, as Niall asked him
what was wrong, “Oh Sensei was correcting me a lot today, I couldn’t seem to get anything right” answered Billy.
“At least Sensei noticed you” said Niall, as he continued up the stairs to the dojo.
So there you have it, giving and receiving feedback, a huge part of our training and development in the martial arts.
Until next month.
Train True, Train hard, Train Often.
Giving and receiving feedback in your martial arts training.
As I began this article, I didn’t realise it would grow into another 2 parter, but as it grew, it naturally evolved and I decided to separate it into part 1,giving and part 2, receiving feedback.
Part 1 Giving Feedback in the Martial Arts,
“That’s very good…. but it could be better”, these were the words of our Taijiquan teacher a few weeks ago, after he watched us doing our long form, there was a small ripple of laughter from the class, as we knew there would be both the carrot and stick.
And I guess that is what this article is about, not just the giving feedback and corrections, but also the attitudes and teaching principles that go along with this.
To continue the above story, our teacher then went on to give the class two pieces of advice to improve our form, and that is the key to giving feedback, there needs to be advice on how to make improvements in what you are doing, otherwise it’s just criticism, which isn’t particularly helpful or productive.
What is essential is a balanced approach (both carrot and stick) and if the instructor is going to criticise the student, as part of their feedback, then it should be constructive criticism, it needs to not only identify the problem, but also offer the solution.
(Too much ‘carrot’ and the student will become complacent and develop a lazy attitude.
Too much ‘stick’ and the student may leave).
Lets set a scenario, to highlight this;
Instructor a) No, no Johnny your front kick is rubbish.
Instructor b) No, Johnny your front kick is too low.
Instructor c) Ok Johnny, that’s a good try, but with the front kick, we need to get the knee nice and high, for the next few kicks, just try lifting the knee nice and high, lift it as high as your belt.
Instructor d) That’s it Johnny, OK.
As we can see, the first instructor (A) just gives criticism, which is no good to the Johnny the student, it may feed some ego driven need of the teacher, but it does more harm than good for the student.
Instructor B, identifies the problem, i.e. the kick is too low, however gives no guidance on how to correct the problem.
The 3rd Instructor (c) identifies the problem, and gives precise feedback on how to correct the problem, they also allow extra practice for these corrections, and a simple goal that the student can use to work on their technique.
Instructor d – doesn’t care enough to give correction, or doesn’t want to risk upsetting his student or their parents (in whose eyes can do nothing wrong).
Did you notice anything else with the feedback?
The first two instructors personalise the problem with the student – it’s their front kick, that is the problem.
Instructor three, describes the technique and what is needed to make it better.
When I took my Instructors course with the British Aikido Board, we were advised to give only 2 or 3 corrections per student, per lesson, in other words avoid over correction.
I have had teachers in the past, who could have really improved their lessons by heeding this advice, one in particular, would over correct, to the point when I was at home after the lesson and began to fill in my training journal, there was so much information, I forgot the main points he had corrected and talked about.
So keep your corrections (feedback) short and to the point.
Correct the main thing first, so by this I mean as the student progresses, hopefully the feedback you’re giving should become less frequent and more detailed.
It;s of little use, to try to explain some fine technical detail to a student on their first lesson, when what they need to know is what arm and leg to use, and what direction they should be facing.
Avoid Jargon where possible, so one of the unique problems facing martial arts instructors, is when and how often to use the foreign terms for the style they are teaching, our styles may include Japanese, Korean, Cantonese etc.
Obviously the senior grade students should have a reasonable grasp of the terminology we use in class, however it can introduce a learning barrier for the beginner.
Many instructors are moving into a ‘freestyle’ space, and are no longer using terminology in their lessons, however a talented and experienced teacher will know when and how to introduce this terminology, and as a traditionalist I enjoy the learning of this terminology.
On the subject of language, we need to consider how we speak to students when giving corrections and feedback, if you find yourself giving the same advice over and over, then either the student isn’t getting the message, or the student doesn’t care enough to change his behaviour.
Types of learning, there are different learning models, for this we can use the VARK model (visual, auditory, reading, kinetic).
So if you’re message isn’t getting through, maybe try a different method, teaching isn’t a one size fits all situation, if you have younger students, discuss this with their parents (especially important to those on the neuro-diverse spectrum).
Just like my Sensei, obviously when we begin teaching, we use our own teachers as models to follow (hopefully backed up by coaching and instructor courses) however don’t be afraid to break those shackles and find your own teaching style, don’t hide behind your black belt and instructors certificate, allow your personality to shine through.
I believe martial arts should be open to everyone, not just the physically and intellectually gifted.
As instructors, it’s our responsibility and privileged to preserve and pass on these ancient ways in a modern and fast changing society.
(Next month part 2 – receiving feedback)
Train true, train hard, train often.
So remember six months ago, back in January, we set ourselves the goals for this New Year of 2026, we looked at two different ‘models’ for setting goals, those being AIMS (achievable, Incremental, measurable, specific) & SMART (specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, time bound).
I wrote about breaking down those goals into smaller ones to help make them achievable and being very specific about what those goals were.
A key feature in working towards our goals, is to review them on a regular basis, so here we are 6 months on, lets review them.
Are you still making good progress towards your main goal?
Did you break the main goal down, into smaller ones, are you achieving these?
How did you decide how to measure your progress?
Were you specific about your goals, did you write them down, and set time scales?
So when I set my goals for 2026, I had 3 in mind.
One very specific and two secondary (on-going) goals, so 6 months in, lets see how they’re going.
Main Goal : Complete the Baat Cham Dao form
Time Scale: 12 months
Broken down: Into 8 sections
Review & assessment: regular reviews and assessments
So it seems that my ambition and enthusiasm in January was slightly over confident, so when those winter dreams of the New Year hit the reality of life, I have had to seriously re-adjust my time scale.
So here we are at the end of month 6, and I have so far only managed to complete the first 3 sections, so I now have re-adjusted my time scale, to roll into 2027.
Allow myself 3 months per section, and look to complete the first 5 sections to a high standard by November, and begin section 6 in January.
Secondary Goal: improve overall stamina and functional strength
Time scale: 12 months and on-going
Review & assessment: measure performance in weight sets / reps / time / distance
So things were going very well for a few months, I managed to improve my distance and increase my weight capacity.
However I increased the weights on the seated abdominal trainer, too much and caused myself a back injury. So I have taken a break from the gym for a few weeks.
Tertiary Goal: Continue Taijiquan practice
Time Scale: 12 months and on-going
Broken down: add postures every week of the forms
review & assessment: watched weekly
So of the 3 goals, this is the only one which I haven’t had to adjust or reset, In truth, I’m finding it difficult to remember the long form, and the general lack of space discourages me somewhat from practising at home, but apart from that, this goal seems to be on track, so far.
So there we are, life often gets in way.
But as martial artists, it is important to learn from these setbacks, we endure and grow because of these problems, not in spite of them.
It is absolutely fine, to re-adjust your goals and allow yourself more time.
Make sure you don’t abandon them, keep going.
Remember, failure isn’t falling down, failure is not getting up and trying again.
Train true, train hard, train often
So not really a third part to the previous 2 articles about the benefits of martial arts training, more of a post script.
So I found myself approaching the keyboard with a certain amount of trepidation, as this subject can be quite divisive in the martial arts world.
This subject of internal energy Chi, Qi or Ki power, it seems you have one opinion or the other, it is so polarising it is hard to have a foot in both camps, although there are martial artists who try this and I count myself among them.
I should probably add a caveat to this, before I begin the article, and that is that I’m quite a pragmatic person, rather than an artistic person.
I’m more interested in the physical anatomical mechanics of how techniques work.
I’ve found that people with a creative or artistic personalities find the subject of internal energy a bit easier to grasp (as they are able to visualise easier).
Lastly if your here to find my expert opinion, unfortunately you wont find it, because I don’t have one, i’m still stumbling around in the dark with a dull candle in this vastness of belief, information and practised experiences.
It’s a subject I find equally fascinating and frustrating, and I can only share here my experiences and thoughts on the subject.
So when I began training in the mid 1980’s there was no google or youtube, the only sources of information (other than our teachers) were a handful of books at the local library or martial arts magazines.
Being a studious person (or a nerd) I would read these, and I would from time to time here about this mysterious Chi energy, as a child I didn’t really fully understand what this was about and I imagined some kind of Jedi like invisible force.
At the time I was practising Karate, so our focus was on the physical aspects of training, the articles I read were often around the Chinese systems of Kung Fu, so after a short break from Karate, I found and joined a Kung Fu (Wu Shu) class and spent the next few years training there, although the training was similar to the physical training of karate.
So apart from continuing to read about the subject, as I entered my late teens, and now training in Taekwondo, I became fully committed to my physical practise, sparring, fitness training and competing in tournaments.
The subject was still on the back of my mind and intriguing, so when I found myself in the position of opening my own Taekwondo clubs, I named them Ki Taekwondo.
I attended many martial arts courses over the years, some involving demonstrations of this Chi power, see last years article on the mysterious Hanshi, and at the time these demonstrations seemed impressive, on after thought they didn’t really have any practical application.
So as I continued my training, I came upon Aikido, surely here I would find the answers, afterall ‘ki’ makes up one of the three characters of the system, however we didn’t really do much chi or ki specific exercises, we did things like ‘unbendable arm exercise’ which was supposed to demonstrate non strength based resistance, to direct physical pressure, was this ‘ki’ or just an anatomical parlour trick?
I once asked the head of our association a 7th Dan Shihan, about this Ki energy, his answer was that there was something there, that he (as quite a big person) had been thrown by smaller people, and he had felt something, but he couldn’t explain what that was.
After passing black belt, I decided to travel to different dojo’s and trying to find the answer to this riddle.
At one of these dojo, the idea was that this energy developed naturally through our training, it built up through the lesson, and at the end of the night during cool-downs, class would end with us shaking off the excess Ki ?
Another Sensei I learnt from (who had spent ten years in Japan) wouldn’t describe this vital energy as Ki or Chi, he would describe it as an ‘intention’.
As part of this quest, I took a Reiki course, and I was expecting warming of the hands, or tingling in the palm, and although the course required a practical element which I passed, I didn’t feel anything personally, again there is a previous article on here about that experience.
I ended my twelve year journey in Aikido, by further exploring this subject, by ‘giving up’ my 2nd Dan in tradition Aikido, and once again donning the white belt and I joined a Ki Aikido club,
I thought I could finally unlock this mystery.
The Sensei was really good at giving various demonstrations of this Ki energy.
Again when I tried to pin down an answer I asked him about the subject, he told me that it wasn’t necessarily something he could teach, however when I heard a phrase or description it may ‘unlock’ it for me, For him it was to imagine that his spine had been replace by a fluorescent light tube, and somehow for him, that worked.
We don’t really talk about Chi in Wing Chun, although I have studied with an ‘internal Wing Chun teacher’ who would always emphasize the unconscious mind, and using the relaxed natural energy of the body that occurs on a subconscious level, rather than trying to use power, this was really interesting, however the lessons were online and it didn’t really work in this medium.
So last year to continue this journey of discovery I began training in Tai Chi, the first teacher I trained with talked about Chi a lot, this exercise develops Chi, this exercise improves the bodies immune system etc.
During one of these exercises, working with a partner I did get the feeling of warm tingling in the palm of my hands (as I had expected to feel during the Reiki course) I remember coming home excited and telling my wife of this experience, she looked up from her phone screen ‘uh uh’ was her reply…bless her.
Was this Chi energy or an example of groupthink or conformity (normative influence).
Perhaps I’m just too sceptical to believe in this type of invisible force?
Examples that I’ve witnessed, are they Chi?
- I’ve witnessed someone receiving acupuncture (one of my Wing Chun teachers was a TCM practitioner) performed this on someone’s forearm, to heal a bad knee, which seemed to work and relieve the symptoms.
- The Ki Aikido Sensei, standing on one leg, and holding out his opposite arm, with students pushing against him and being able to resist.
- Feeling the warm tingling in my palm after doing various Tai Chi exercises.
- Seeing a demonstrating where someone was moving their hands around someone’s aura or ‘Chi field’ and making them loose balance.
Before completing this article, I thought I would ask my current Taijiquan teacher on their opinion on Chi, here’s what he said.
“This is Chi” he said knocking on the table, “that wall is chi” he said pointing to the wall, “my body is chi” Chi is just energy, “it is not magical or mysterious, if your leading a healthy lifestyle you will develop Chi”.
He asked me to put out my arms, with the gentlest of touches, he unbalanced me, “some people would call that Chi, but it is just me manipulating your balance” he said.
So Chi is energy, and everything in the universe is made of energy, this is now backed up by theories of quantum physics.
And so that is that, is my quest over, for now it is on the back burner, I will continue to train and work to develop my skills, I won’t obsess over this subject for now.
So that is my 40 year journey (so far) and the answers that I haven’t found.
As always;
Train true, train hard, train often.
So this is the 2nd part of the health and fitness benefits of the Martial Arts training, article I wrote last month.
The first thing I’ll address is the elephant in the room, which is this concept of ‘chi’ or ‘ki’ this internal energy which permeates the traditional martial arts, so first of all I’ll say that this particular post won’t be dealing with this primarily because I don’t feel qualified or experienced enough in the subject.
However I won’t be completely ignoring the subject as I’ll be writing another post (next month) not necessarily a third part, but more of a post script, which will be my own personal journey in investigating Chi (or Ki) and my experiences of it.
So last month we looked at the physical side of the subject, the improvements in coaching and having a good well planned, martial arts (cardio) exercise workout.
For many people that’s what their martial arts is all about, a good workout a couple of times a week, when I was younger I was probably trained in this frame of mind a lot of the time, really enjoying a tough pad-work and sparring session or attending the Taekwondo associations monthly squad training sessions.
But as I grow older in the martial arts, this began to change and I can now better appreciate the broader health benefits of martial arts training, beyond the physical.
So the two systems I currently practice are Wing Chun and Tai Chi, and as I mentioned last month, my Wing Chun Sifu, now in his late sixties doesn’t practice any heavy cardio workouts in his classes.
So what benefits are we talking about, well for a start there is the social aspect of being involved in training, meeting people and being part of a community, even if its just a bunch of middle aged men having a moan (as is my case on a Thursday at Wing Chun).
I see this in the Tai Chi class, where there are a few seniors their, it’s a good time to have a catch up and talk before class starts.
This can also lead to expanding your friendship circle to fellow instructors, even of different styles to hold seminars at each others clubs, thus breaking down the pre justices between clubs and leading students to appreciate the differences in other martial arts styles.
Of course the great thing with the Tai Chi exercise is the focus on health, the slow breathing and movements to keep the body working and the joints open, manageable for the older generation, and this is another one of those benefits, that of leading to a healthier lifestyle and a greater interest in general wellness and well-being (perhaps a healthier diet or weight loss plan).
When we consider the forms and set piece drills of traditional martial arts brings us to a third benefit, that of increased mental agility and improved cognitive memory, this can be very helpful for the senior generation, and maybe this explains the popularity of styles like Tai Chi with the more mature generation.
So we have looked at the social aspects, the promotion general wellness as part of a healthy lifestyle and the mental well-being benefits.
This brings us now onto the topic of ‘self’s’
These being; self discipline, self determination, self control, self confidence (we could also add in here self defence – the non physical aspects of personal safety and situational awareness)
So here we begin to look at the personal development side of the traditional martial arts, working on the ‘self’, when the traditional Japanese Budo arts changed from being ‘Jitsu’ skilful combat arts, to ‘Do’ martial ways, we saw this development and change of mindset, from simply training to become better warriors, to working on the greater self to become better human beings, through our hard training and dedication to practice.
You may have heard the old saying of “forging the steel of our soul, in the furnaces of the dojo”.
So our self determination is achieved in many ways by this continuous turning up, training hard and learning new skills.
As my Taijiquan teacher recently reminded us in class;
“Yes it is difficult, but that is why we’re here to do the difficult things”
Modern life seems to encourage a sedentary lifestyle, with a lot of sitting (our jobs, our cars, our commuting) whilst we interact with social media, or binge the latest TV show.
It is very hard sometimes to leave our warm comfy armchair, especially in winter, when its wet, dark and cold, but that is how we constantly work on our determination and discipline, as we learn new martial skills we are also changing our mindset, working on ourselves, chipping away our ego to find our greater self.
Along with these increased martial arts skills, comes (hopefully) an understanding of self control, just because we have these abilities to hurt people, doesn’t mean that we have to.
Self Confidence comes through the realisation and awareness of the student’s growing skill and competence in the martial arts, this being supported by encouragement by their teacher, a note of caution here however, we are trying to develop self confidence, not arrogance.
These underlying principles of self development, form the underpinning of traditional martial arts philosophy, which we find in notions like the seven virtues of Budo (Rectitude, courage, benevolence, respect, honesty, honour, loyalty) and the five tenets of Taekwondo (etiquette, modesty, perseverance, self control, indomitable spirit).
So all this is about ‘forging’ our better self through the tough experiences of our practice, and of course this is the work of a lifetime, it is not something achievable in a week or two.
As I was drafting this article out, we had the sad passing of martial arts legend Chuck Norris.
So I will leave you with a quote credited the him about self control.
“Man, Like steel looses his worth, when he looses his temper”
Next month a post script article about my journey to discover and experiences with this mysterious Chi energy.
Train True, Train Hard, Train Often.
Lets start this months article with a hypothetical situation and question.
A family friend who knows you are interested or involved in martial arts, asks you your opinion on whether their son, little Jimmy, should start martial arts to improve their fitness?
You could of course give a quick off the cuff answer of – yeah sure, give It a try, I’m sure Jimmy will enjoy it.
Or you could ask a question or two of your own, such as
which club / style are you thinking of? How fit is Jimmy trying to get?
If the answer is a Taekwondo, kick-boxing or one of these numerous freestyle classes. Then yes these will all have a cardio fitness element to them and i’m sure Jimmy will enjoy training and increase his fitness.
I think looking back over my 4 decades in martial arts, one of the biggest improvements that I’ve seen, is the improvements in the coaching standards.
Most NGB’s (National Governing Bodies) Organisations, Associations, Federations etc, have now placed some requirement on a sports coaching qualification in order to be classed as an instructor.
This notion of a ‘Black Belt’ grade being the only standard required to teach is being phased out and not before time.
Back in the good (bad) old days of martial arts, they often had this old school mentality of their training was brutal, so I in turn will perpetuate this brutality on to my students, there was no room for common sense or to have the audacity to question the ‘old ways’ of doing things.
Starting my martial arts journey in the mid 1980’s I came across a few of these ‘old school’ Sensei’s myself, where the dojo attitude was one of ‘brute force and ignorance’, where we did stupid things like ‘duck walking’ and ‘bunny hops’ around the hall, which were probably doing more harm than good in terms of a physical exercise, along with step ups on to a table, and wheel barrow races – where the person being moved would be on their knuckles.
So I’m glad to say these old ways are on there way out, although just thirteen years ago, I was training with a Sensei who would stamp on your stomach, during sit-ups.
Hopefully this example is an exception to the rule, and these ‘old school ways’ are fading away,
Now there is nothing wrong with hard training of course, but this hard training must be done sensibly and safely, under the guidance of a qualified instructor.
Starting with a good warm ups, raising the heart rate and respiratory rate (ready for peak exercise) and then finishing with a cool down.
So normal resting heart rate is around 60 to 100 beats per minute (bpm), athletes often have a lower resting rate of 40 to 60 bpm.
This should be gradually raised (during warm ups) to a safe moderate intensity, which is based on your age, fitness level and any physical impediments or illnesses, which all need to be taken into account when working with your students, who need to treated with respect and as individuals when it comes down to health and fitness, this shouldn’t be a one size fits all situation.
Picture this as a arc (or semi-circle) where we having a standing start (resting heart rate) rising up gradually until we reach peak exercise level and then lower it down back to resting rate.
We shouldn’t accept the excuse of ‘toughening us up’ used by our teaches, as a substitute for a good sensible warm up, cool down, stamina and cardio workout as part of the physical component of your martial arts training.
If in doubt (before joining a club) check if the organisations has a coaching scheme in place, or the individual coaching qualifications of the instructor.
Now depending on the art / style in question, will also depend on how much physical exercise will be part of their curriculum
For example my teachers (Wing Chun and Tai Chi) don’t teach or include a physical workout in their class, we start class with a gentle warm up of opening the joints and light stretching, long gone are the days of running about, sit ups, push ups etc.
In these cases if you’re looking to study martial arts which don’t include a fitness regimen but also want to keep fit and healthy, you should take personal responsibility for this and (like I have recently) join a gym.
Like I’ve said, I’m personally in favour of training being challenging, So I would hate for things go too far in the direction of not pushing ourselves physically, or for classes getting too easy.
I’m a big believer to the notion of growth through adversity.
People start martial arts for many different reasons, physical fitness may or may not be one of those reasons, perhaps the potential student is being bullied at school, so the last thing they need is to face another bully twice a week, only this one is wearing a black belt.
Next months article,
Health and fitness in martial arts (part 2) The internal health benefits of martial arts.
As always; Train true, train hard, train often.
I recently received the sad news that the Former president of the British Taekwon-do Association passed away in October 2025.
I joined the BTA in 1993, as a green tag, having previously trained with a club affiliated with the European Taekwon-do Union and remained a member until 2011, as a 5th Dan, when I left Taekwon-do to focus on my Aikido.
When I first joined the association Master Kilner was the association’s registrar and senior instructor, sitting on the grading panels alongside other Masters and Grandmasters.
Along side expanding his own club, he also continued his own improvement rising through the grades to through to 9th Dan Grandmaster.
Master Kilner had also by this time had been nominated to the position of President of the association, a large responsibility, but one he seemed to relish and sought to expand the association beyond the art of Taekwon-do and into the wider world of martial arts.
Roy was an instructor who taught with enthusiasm and positivity, whilst maintaining the traditional values and etiquette of the art.
His club was the venue the BTA used to host the black-belt Dan grades, and I took several of my students there to grade under him and Grandmaster Tony Quigley.
Master Kilner spent 60 years training and later teaching the art, and shortly before his passing and group of senior UK black-belts from various organisations, awarded Roy an honorary 10th Dan for his dedication and services to the art of Taekwon-do and the wider martial arts.
I’ll always remember Roy fondly, a personality that could fill the room, always full of positivity, he gave so much of himself to his students and the martial arts, providing a positive outlet for the young people he taught, not only to become good martial arts students, but also helping them to become respectful, hard-working individuals who can contribute that same positivity into their communities.

3 Grandmasters – (L-R) Roy Kilner, Tony Quigley, Mark Trent